Public dossier nº 001/Not yet filed/Federal Court of Canada

The evidence
was never missing.It was withheld.

A public framework for a class action against the Crown in right of Canada — setting out the causes of action, the standard of proof, and the exhibits required to establish breach of fiduciary duty, breach of public trust, and the suppression of a scientific record Canadians were entitled to see.

04
Causes of action
08
Exhibit classes
00
Findings of fact
Fig. 01
Specimen record. Evidence that exists is not the same as evidence that is disclosed.
A-01 — Regulatory recordStandard — What the regulator knew before it decided, and who inside the institution knew it.A-02 — Peer-reviewed literatureStandard — Whether the evidence base was available, public, and reproducible outside Canada.A-03 — Judicial and commission recordStandard — That the questions are justiciable, and how they have already been answered elsewhere.A-04 — Access-to-information recordStandard — The pattern of disclosure itself, which is often the strongest exhibit.A-05 — Legislative and executive recordStandard — What the Crown said publicly against what its own files show.A-06 — Sworn testimonyStandard — Matters that leave no paper trail but are capable of being tested under cross-examination.A-07 — Post-market dataStandard — Whether post-authorisation signals were received and what followed from them.A-08 — International comparisonStandard — That the Canadian position was a choice among available alternatives, not a necessity.A-01 — Regulatory recordStandard — What the regulator knew before it decided, and who inside the institution knew it.A-02 — Peer-reviewed literatureStandard — Whether the evidence base was available, public, and reproducible outside Canada.A-03 — Judicial and commission recordStandard — That the questions are justiciable, and how they have already been answered elsewhere.A-04 — Access-to-information recordStandard — The pattern of disclosure itself, which is often the strongest exhibit.A-05 — Legislative and executive recordStandard — What the Crown said publicly against what its own files show.A-06 — Sworn testimonyStandard — Matters that leave no paper trail but are capable of being tested under cross-examination.A-07 — Post-market dataStandard — Whether post-authorisation signals were received and what followed from them.A-08 — International comparisonStandard — That the Canadian position was a choice among available alternatives, not a necessity.
IThe charges

Four causes of action, each with a test the Crown must meet.

A case is not a position. Each ground below is stated with the elements that would have to be proved, so that the argument can be examined element by element rather than accepted or rejected whole.

01

Breach of Fiduciary Duty

In taking custody of the national scientific record, the Crown placed itself in a position of trust over information Canadians cannot obtain for themselves. A fiduciary may not use that position for its own purposes. Where evidence was held by the state and kept from the people it described, the duty of loyalty is engaged.

Duty·Breach·Loss
02

Misfeasance in Public Office

This tort does not require a statute to be broken. It requires a public officer to exercise lawful authority unlawfully, either knowing the harm that would follow, or with reckless indifference to it. The framework treats the question as evidentiary: who knew, when, and what did they do next.

Authority·Knowledge·Unlawful act·Harm
03

Suppression & Non-Disclosure

The central factual question is narrow and answerable. What did the Crown know, at what date did it know it, and what was done with the knowledge once it was in hand? A record that exists and is not disclosed is a different matter from a record that never existed.

Known·Held·Withheld
04

Negligent Misrepresentation

Where a regulator issues statements of settled certainty while the underlying record supports doubt, a duty of care is owed to the people who relied on that statement and arranged their lives, their treatment and their families around it.

Duty of care·Untrue statement·Reliance·Detriment
IIEvidence protocol

Eight exhibit classes. One standard: a traceable source.

The ledger is organised before it is filled, so that no exhibit can be added simply because it is believed. Each class records what must be obtained and what it is capable of proving.

A-01Class

Regulatory record

Pre-authorisation files, review memoranda, advisory committee minutes, and the internal correspondence surrounding them.

Proves · What the regulator knew before it decided, and who inside the institution knew it.

A-02Class

Peer-reviewed literature

International replication studies, systematic reviews and meta-analyses published in indexed journals.

Proves · Whether the evidence base was available, public, and reproducible outside Canada.

A-03Class

Judicial and commission record

Judgments, inquests and public inquiries in other jurisdictions that have tested the same questions on the same evidence.

Proves · That the questions are justiciable, and how they have already been answered elsewhere.

A-04Class

Access-to-information record

Released documents, refusals, redactions, extensions, and the date of every response.

Proves · The pattern of disclosure itself, which is often the strongest exhibit.

A-05Class

Legislative and executive record

Hansard, committee testimony, mandate letters, briefing notes and ministerial correspondence.

Proves · What the Crown said publicly against what its own files show.

A-06Class

Sworn testimony

Statements from practitioners, reviewers, former officials and patients, taken under oath where possible.

Proves · Matters that leave no paper trail but are capable of being tested under cross-examination.

A-07Class

Post-market data

Adverse event reporting, signal detection, and the internal handling of both.

Proves · Whether post-authorisation signals were received and what followed from them.

A-08Class

International comparison

How peer jurisdictions regulated, funded, published or restricted the same body of evidence.

Proves · That the Canadian position was a choice among available alternatives, not a necessity.

Statement
“A regulator is entrusted with information it alone can collect. That trust is the whole basis of its authority. When the record is held and the public is told the question is settled, the breach is not of a statute — it is of the trust that made the statute possible.”
Known

What the institution held on a given date.

Disclosed

What the public was told, and when.

Consequence

What followed from the distance between them.

IIIThe class

Who a certified class would cover.

A class must be identifiable before it can be certified. These four groups are the proposed membership — described by circumstance rather than by opinion, because a class defined by belief cannot be certified.

i

Patients and families

People denied access to treatment supported by the record, or who consented to a course of care on the strength of a statement the record did not support.

ii

Practitioners

Clinicians investigated, disciplined, de-licensed or silenced for following evidence they were entitled to rely on.

iii

The injured

Those who suffered measurable harm from a scientific record that existed, was held, and was not disclosed.

iv

The public

Every Canadian who relied on a public statement of certainty issued over a record that supported doubt.

NoteFrom the creator

One page, in plain language, on why this record was built and what it asks of the country.

Read the note

“A cure is a competitor to a revenue stream. When income depends on a condition persisting, the evidence that it could be resolved is not debated — it is buried.”

Obscurity is not a refutation · Obscurity is a breach of trust
The record

A case is built from documents. If you hold one, it belongs in the ledger.

Registration is a record of your circumstances, not an allegation and not a claim. Every entry is reviewed before it is used. Nothing you submit is published without your consent.

Open a fileSubmit an exhibit

Not legal advice. Time limits apply. Consult counsel in your own province.